With NO WATER, there's NO FOOD, PEOPLE, or HISTORY!

According to the Standard Islamic Narrative, Mecca has been a city which has existed since the time of Adam and Eve, so it is the oldest city in history.

It is where Abraham lived in 1900 BC (see Surah 21:51-71), so it has to be pretty historical.

It is also where Muhammad was born and lived for his first 52 years, so it must have been around by the 6th - 7th centuries.

But there is a problem with these accounts, because in order for Mecca to be that historical it needs one simple ingredient...WATER.

And Mecca is in a desert, with little to no water at all (Note: the Zam-Zam well we will soon prove is not historical at all either).

So, why is water important?

•Where there is a desert, there’s no water

•Where there is no water, there’s no food

•Where there is no food, there’s no people

•Where there are no people, there’s no towns

•Where there are no towns, there’s no cities

•Where there are no cities, there’s no civilization

•Where there is no civilization, there’s NO HISTORY!

And if Mecca has no history, than Muhammad could have not come from there.

If there is no one named Muhammad living in Mecca, than there can be no Qur'an.

Without Mecca, Muhammad, or the Qur'an, then there is simply no Islam.

They all depend on WATER!

So, the next time a Muslim starts waxing eloquent about his prophet living in Mecca and doing all these wonderful things there...simply remind him of two words - NO WATER...

© Pfander Centre for Apologetics - US, 2022
(62,380) Music: "Justice and Fame" by Rafael Krux, from filmmusic-io