Why No Attorney Would Defend RetroSpectre84 *Copyright Case*

Why No Attorney Would Defend RetroSpectre84 *Copyright Case*

"In this video, we delve into a complex and contentious issue surrounding the alleged copyright infringement involving YouTuber RetroSpectre84 and Doctor K. This case highlights the challenges that arise when AI-generated music intersects with traditional copyright laws, and why RetroSpectre's defenses fall flat when scrutinized under legal principles.

▶️ CHAPTERS
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

00:00 - Case Overview
02:06 - Coldplay vs Joe Satriani 2009 Case
06:21 - Retrospectre84's strawman argument
06:35 - Youtube and DMCA gives green light to strike
07:43 - Retrospectre's weak argument and my OBJECTION!
08:29 - My community board wording for all to see, was worded in suspicion not as fact
09:35 - copyright infringement addresses the end product not process
09:57 - My content was uploaded to youtube first and my music is monetized on rumble
11:01 - Suno is not a monetizatble social media platform, it has no copyright protection
11:25 - Chat GPT Legal Analysis
15:37 - for Copyright only DMCA matter
15:46 - Retrospectre's personal attacks and threats
17:36 - Overview of DMCA process
19:55 - A.I did it is not a defense, you prompted it, you uploaded it

RetroSpectre's Defense:
RetroSpectre84 attempted to justify his actions by claiming that his tracks were generated by Suno.ai, an AI music tool. He argued that the similarities were coincidental and that he didn't directly remix or download Doctor K's music. He also pointed out that his tracks were generated before Doctor K's YouTube releases, though they were uploaded afterward. However, Suno.ai's current legal troubles, including class action lawsuits from major music labels like UMG and Warner Brothers, cast doubt on the legitimacy of claiming copyright ownership through AI-generated content.

Why RetroSpectre's Defense Fails:

AI Doesn't Shield You from Copyright Law: Simply using AI to generate music doesn't exempt a creator from respecting existing copyrights. RetroSpectre84's argument that the AI generated similar tracks doesn't absolve him of responsibility, especially when his final products were released on YouTube and closely mirrored Doctor K's protected work.

Timing and Platform Matter: RetroSpectre's claim that his music was generated earlier is irrelevant when considering that Doctor K's music was the first to be published on major platforms like YouTube and Rumble, both of which offer copyright protection. The fact that RetroSpectre released his tracks after Doctor K's public releases undermines his defense.

Failure to Dispute the DMCA: If RetroSpectre genuinely believed in the legitimacy of his claims, he would have disputed the DMCA takedown through YouTube's official channels. Instead, he resorted to vague threats and accusations outside the platform, which only weakens his position further.

Creative Commons Misuse: RetroSpectre labeled one of his tracks as "Creative Commons," potentially allowing others to use and distribute content that was over 75% similar to Doctor K's original work. This not only violates copyright laws but also risks spreading infringing content further, compounding the legal implications.

#CopyrightInfringement #AI #dmca #IntellectualProperty #Sunolawsuit #YouTubeMusic #CreativeCommons"

"Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism,
comment, Satirical Parody
news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use."

This video is classed as my criticism of the claims and education on copyright laws and legality

Original Infringing Article:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VZ18JxTGNU8
This track copied note for note from my Derpira Track

Creative Commons:
Scott Buckley - 'Legionnaire' [Epic Orchestral CC-BY]
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7uIYYEM45b4
Subscribe to Scott Buckley! @ScottBuckley