Premium Only Content
Insurer Not Required to Take on the Burden of the Insured's Fraud
Rescission Appropriate When Insured Lies on Application
Post 4827
Progressive Michigan Insurance Company (Progressive) appealed the order denying its motion for summary disposition and ordering reformation of plaintiff's, Janice Sherman's, automobile insurance policy even when reformation was not requested by Sherman.
In Janice Sherman v. Progressive Michigan Insurance Company and JOHN DOE, No. 364393, Court of Appeals of Michigan (June 20, 2024) the Court of Appeals explained the importance of the equitable remedy of rescission.
BACKGROUND FACTS
On November 12, 2020, Sherman applied to Progressive for a no-fault insurance policy for two vehicles-a 2006 Cadillac DTS sedan and a 1993 Chrysler New Yorker sedan. In the application, she identified her address as 16845 Tremlett Drive, Clinton Township, MI 48035, and confirmed that the vehicles were garaged at this address. The application also failed to disclose the total number of resident relatives, 14 years of age or older, and "all regular drivers" of her vehicles then residing in her household.
Progressive's litigation underwriting specialist, Janeen Copic, submitted an affidavit stating that Progressive would have charged a 7.7% higher premium had Sherman accurately disclosed the number of drivers and resident-relatives at the reported address, and a 75.5% increased premium had Sherman disclosed her permanent Detroit residence.
THE ACCIDENT
On July 14, 2021, Sherman was a passenger in one of the vehicles when it was hit from behind by John Doe. She was injured in this accident and asked Progressive for personal protection insurance (PIP) benefits. Progressive refused while rescinding the policy ab initio because of misrepresentations in her application. Sherman lied about the location where the cars were garaged and other individuals resided with her who she did not list on her application. Progressive estimated that, had Sherman included this additional information, it would have increased her premium by 83.2%.
THE SUIT
Sherman then sued Doe and Progressive claiming it unlawfully refused to pay PIP benefits and had breached her insurance contract. Sherman claimed the remedy should be tailored to the equities of the situation and needed to produce a fair result for all parties. The trial ordered that the policy be reformed to reflect the "insurance premium that [Progressive] believes it would have been entitled to had the insured listed Detroit as the residence.".
SUMMARY DISPOSITION
Summary disposition is appropriate if there is no genuine issue regarding any material fact and the moving party is entitled to judgment as a matter of law.
An insurer has a reasonable right to expect honesty in the application for insurance. Indeed, it is well settled that an insurer is entitled to rescind a policy ab initio on the basis of a material misrepresentation made in an application for no-fault insurance. A misrepresentation is material if the insurer would have rejected the risk or charged an increased premium and would not have issued the same contract had it been given the correct information.
Even if fraud is not established rescission is justified in cases of innocent misrepresentation if a party relies upon the misstatement, because otherwise the party responsible for the misstatement would be unjustly enriched if he were not held accountable for his misrepresentation.
There was no reason in law or policy for the burden of such a risk to be placed on the insurer in preference to the insured who made the intentional material misrepresentations. The trial court's balance of the equities should have revealed misconduct by Sherman, but none by Progressive.
The Court of Appeals concluded that the trial court erred by failing to recognize this distinction. By ordering the policy reformed, the trial court placed the financial burden of paying PIP benefits on Progressive, notwithstanding the fact that Sherman obtained those very same benefits by way of fraud. The trial court erred when it ordered reformation, rather than rescission and its order was reversed.
ZALMA OPINION
Rescission is an ancient equitable remedy that exists because it would be unfair to allow one party to a contract to profit from fraud in the obtaining of a contract of insurance. Sherman lied in the application requesting an offer of insurance about the location and available drivers which, had she told the truth, would have resulted in much higher premiums. The trial court trying to be fair wrongfully refused rescission but used another equitable remedy: reformation to require the victim of Sherman's fraud, Progressive, with the medical expenses. Neither Ms. Sherman nor anyone should be allowed to profit from their fraud.
(c) 2024 Barry Zalma & ClaimSchool, Inc.
Please tell your friends and colleagues about this blog and the videos and let them subscribe to the blog and the videos.
Subscribe to my substack at https://barryzalma.substack.com/subscribe
Go to X @bzalma; Go to Newsbreak.com https://www.newsbreak.com/@c/1653419?s=01; Go to Barry Zalma videos at Rumble.com at https://rumble.com/c/c-262921; Go to Barry Zalma on YouTube- https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCysiZklEtxZsSF9DfC0Expg.
Go to the Insurance Claims Library – https://lnkd.in/gwEYk
-
1:03:45
Donald Trump Jr.
8 hours agoHappy Festivus: Airing Our Grievances and Stopping The Swamp w/Sean Davis | TRIGGERED Ep.201
112K187 -
1:58:10
Robert Gouveia
6 hours agoMatt Gaetz REJECTS Report, Sues Committee; Luigi Fan Club Arrives; Biden Commutes; Festivus Waste
50.7K61 -
58:10
Kimberly Guilfoyle
8 hours agoAmerica is Back & The Future is Bright: A Year in Review | Ep. 183
44.4K43 -
3:03:27
vivafrei
13 hours agoEp. 242: Barnes is BACK AGAIN! Trump, Fani, J6, RFK, Chip Roy, USS Liberty AND MORE! Viva & Barnes
92.8K51 -
8:09:50
Dr Disrespect
11 hours ago🔴LIVE - DR DISRESPECT - MARVEL RIVALS - GOLD VANGUARD
175K30 -
1:15:00
Awaken With JP
10 hours agoMerry Christmas NOT Happy Holidays! Special - LIES Ep 71
130K109 -
1:42:21
The Quartering
11 hours agoTrump To INVADE Mexico, Take Back Panama Canal Too! NYC Human Torch & Matt Gaetz Report Drops!
109K92 -
2:23:15
Nerdrotic
11 hours ago $11.42 earnedA Very Merry Christmas | FNT Square Up - Nerdrotic Nooner 453
86.9K11 -
1:14:05
Tucker Carlson
10 hours ago“I’ll Win With or Without You,” Teamsters Union President Reveals Kamala Harris’s Famous Last Words
173K337 -
1:58:31
The Dilley Show
10 hours ago $32.63 earnedTrump Conquering Western Hemisphere? w/Author Brenden Dilley 12/23/2024
137K39