The Best Madden on the Xbox 360 & PS3

While Madden NFL 11's gameplay wasn’t as well done as All-Pro Football 2K8’s, and while its presentation wasn’t as good as ESPN NFL 2K5’s, and while its franchise mode wasn’t as deep as it was on PS2 Maddens, for an EA Sports game on the seventh generation of consoles, this was as good as it would get. Don’t get me wrong, I had a lot of fun with Madden NFL 11 and I think it’s a really solid NFL game for its time, but it being the best Madden of its generation yet still falling short of 2K’s older titles proves that EA was the wrong choice for the exclusive NFL license.