Is the Sermon on the Mount a literary creation? A response to Mike Winger (and Michael Jones)
Pastor Mike Winger seems to think that the Sermon on the Mount and the Sermon on the Plain were actual sermons given word-for-word by the historical Jesus on two different occasions. In this video, I walk through some of the reasons for thinking the Sermon on the Mount is in fact a literary creation of the first evangelist. Along the way, I also respond briefly to Michael Jones regarding the missionary discourse in the Synoptics.
Mike Winger's videos:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OhV-q2DS-bU
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ePKWFPESfZs
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-GAGA9wnJ7k
Michael Jones's video:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nDzHMe7Bb60
Errata:
1. In the quote I read by Christopher Tuckett, I forgot to mention that even though he was talking about the Griesbach hypothesis, his point is still valid on any Synoptic hypothesis where Matthew is not an eyewitness.
2. In the Gruen quote, I mis-pronounce "progress". Oops!
Image credits:
https://4000jesuspictures.com/704-jesus-children/kingdom-of-heaven/otto-a-stemler-01.jpg.html
https://www.ncregister.com/blog/was-st-peter-the-greatest-disciple
https://www.getty.edu/art/collection/object/103RG2
0:00 Intro
0:55 The scholarly view
3:37 How ancient authors remembered speeches
10:00 How the Synoptic authors used their sources
16:08 A contradiction in the Missionary Discourse
18:31 The Sermon on the Mount
19:40 Conclusion
-
1:35:19
Glenn Greenwald
8 hours agoIran's Missile Retaliation Against Israel: What Does It Mean For The U.S. & The Region? Plus: VP Debate Reaction On Locals | SYSTEM UPDATE #344
188K184 -
Fresh and Fit
9 hours agoIran Launches Massive Missile Attack On Israel
190K41 -
4:27:53
WeAreChange
7 hours agoLIVE W/ Alex Jones & Roger Stone: Vance vs. Walz, HOT CONFLICT Igniting!
129K35 -
Slightly Offensive
9 hours agoTHE MOST RETARDED VP DEBATE STREAM | Guest: Breanna Morello
74.4K27 -
Josh Pate's College Football Show
8 hours agoChaotic Saturday Coming | Full Week 6 Predictions | New JP Poll | Added Best Bets
47.7K3 -
55:28
Flyover Conservatives
1 day agoThe Fight for Minnesota: Illegal Voting and Tim Walz’s Radical Agenda - Sen. Eric Lucero & Rep. Walter Hudson; Economic Update - Dr. Kirk Elliott | FOC Show
55.3K2 -
Michael Franzese
13 hours agoReacting to this week's headlines | Michael Franzese LIVE! Ep. 21
60.4K23 -
1:07:33
Edge of Wonder
8 hours agoHurricane Helene Devastates N.C.: Was Weather Modification Involved?
34.4K18 -
10:34
Tundra Tactical
12 hours agoKamala Harris says 2A For Me, NoA for YOU!!!
24.8K9 -
The Big Mig™
10 hours agoSabo The Rebel, Provocateur, Troll, & Genius
30.7K6