1. Justin Bieber and Hailey Seen in Aspen

    Justin Bieber and Hailey Seen in Aspen

    4
  2. See Justin Bieber's Sweet Shoutout to Hailey Bieber | E! News

    See Justin Bieber's Sweet Shoutout to Hailey Bieber | E! News

    4
  3. Justin & Hailey Bieber: Is the Marriage Falling Apart?

    Justin & Hailey Bieber: Is the Marriage Falling Apart?

    23